Want Your Teen Daughter To Talk To You? Try Playing Pretend Again

One of the biggest surprises to me as I raise a tween daughter is how little she still feels. I see so much of her toddler self in how she regulates, how she lets me know she needs me (begging for more bedtime cuddles, following me into the kitchen), and even how she plays with her little sisters. But for all of the things you hear about tweens and teens, one of the most parroted is how they want nothing to do with you once they reach a certain age. I’m honestly not so sure that’s the case… and one mom on TikTok agrees. Alyson Johnson, aka @thebusinessofgolf on social media, recently shared that she stumbled upon the “secret” of getting her teenage daughter to talk to you. Speaking straight to the camera, she tells a story of her 14-year-old getting frustrated over not having something to wear, and instead of getting onto her for it or telling her it wasn’t important — you know, all the things we can see ourselves saying when our teen is having a crash-out — she says she reverted back to how she would’ve handled it when her kid was little. Enter: pretend play. “I brought her into my closet, and I did this whole big, ‘Oh, are you shopping with us today? Please, let me get you a treat.’ And I gave her a chocolate, and I gave her a beautiful flute of apple cider or something. And I was like, ‘Let me show you some pieces’. And her attitude went from, ‘I hate my life, I don’t like what I’m wearing’ to like, ‘Oh this is kind of fun,’” she recalls. Alyson says this moment is similar to another one she was currently filming about “spa time.” She takes a “plate of tiny things” for her daughter and a glass of wine for herself, and she gives her daughter a blow-out while her daughter “spills the tea” just like in a salon. It’s basically the art of play — without your teen ever realizing it. Alyson points out that having her daughter feel cared for and pampered in this way leads to kinder, better conversations between them. In the caption, she even shares that this was the kind of thing she did when her kids were much smaller, just to be silly, but that the beautiful strategy of distraction still really works with big kids. It makes total sense. By creating these more relaxed and inviting scenarios, it comes off less like an interview, where you just keep hitting your kid with questions and “here’s what you should do” statements, and more like having an easy conversation about something that’s happened. I’ve noticed it with my own tween girl playing with her two little sisters — they seem to work things out through pretend play. So here’s to plates of tiny things and the reminder that even our big kids might still just want to be little with us sometimes.

Teenage years are notoriously difficult for both parents and children. The shift from childhood to adolescence brings about a cascade of changes – physically, emotionally, and socially. It’s a time of rapid growth, identity formation, and increasing independence, often accompanied by mood swings, heightened sensitivity, and a desire for privacy. But amidst all these changes, the vital connection between a parent and teen daughter can often feel strained. The question of “how to communicate” with a teenager frequently tops the list of parental anxieties. It’s a common struggle, and one that doesn’t necessarily require a complete overhaul of your parenting style. Sometimes, a simple shift in approach – a return to the playful, nurturing techniques we used with our younger children – can be surprisingly effective. This article explores the surprisingly effective strategies behind using pretend play to reconnect with your teen daughter, delving into the psychology behind the approach and offering practical tips for implementation.

The Toddler Within: Why Tweens Mimic Their Younger Selves

It’s a common observation: a 16-year-old suddenly demanding a bedtime cuddle, or a 14-year-old exhibiting the same insistent pleading for a treat as a toddler. This isn’t simply nostalgia or a deliberate attempt to manipulate. Developmental psychologists have long recognized that tweens and teens often exhibit behaviors remarkably similar to those of their toddler years. Dr. Laura Markham, a clinical psychologist and author, explains this phenomenon in her work, “Positive Discipline,” noting that as children mature, they unconsciously regress to earlier, more secure ways of communicating and seeking comfort. This regression isn’t a sign of bad behavior; it’s a natural part of the developmental process, primarily driven by the feelings of vulnerability and uncertainty that accompany adolescence. The hormonal shifts, social pressures, and the overwhelming need to establish independence all contribute to a feeling of being ‘lost’ – a feeling that many young teens instinctively seek to resolve through the familiar comfort of a caregiver. Understanding this underlying psychological shift is crucial to approaching communication with empathy and patience. It’s not about “fixing” your teen’s behavior; it’s about recognizing the emotional needs driving it.

Specifically, research from the University of Oregon’s Psychology Department reveals that during early childhood, the brain’s reward system is highly sensitive to social touch and immediate gratification. As children age, this system becomes less responsive, leading to a diminished need for physical affection and frequent rewards. However, the need for emotional security and a sense of connection remains strong. When teens experience stress or anxiety, their brains may instinctively seek the familiar comfort of a caregiver, triggering a regression to earlier, more secure behaviors—behaviors that are often associated with toddlerhood. This isn’t a reflection of disrespect or rebellion; it’s a biological response to a challenging developmental period. Acknowledging this neurological basis can help parents approach these behaviors with understanding rather than frustration.

The Perception of Disconnect: Are Teenagers Really Wanting Less Contact?

The common misconception is that teenagers inherently want less contact with their parents – that they actively push away, seeking solitude and independence. While a desire for personal space is undoubtedly a significant factor, this perception isn’t entirely accurate. Studies by the Pew Research Center consistently show that teenagers generally value their relationships with their parents, even if they express those relationships differently than they did during childhood. The way they express that value, however, can often appear as resistance or withdrawal. Researcher Dr. Michele Borba highlights this in her work on adolescent development, stating that “Teenagers are often attempting to assert their independence and establish their own identities, and one way they do that is by distancing themselves from those who represent the ‘old’ version of themselves – their parents.” This isn’t a deliberate rejection of parental love; it’s a crucial step in the process of self-discovery. Furthermore, a teenager’s reluctance to engage in conversation doesn’t necessarily reflect a lack of interest in what their parents have to say. It could be a sign of feeling overwhelmed, misunderstood, or simply not knowing how to articulate their thoughts and feelings effectively. The perceived “lack of contact” often masks a deeper emotional need for connection and validation.

Consider this scenario: a 17-year-old who consistently avoids eye contact and shuts down conversations when their parents try to initiate dialogue. While it might seem like a deliberate attempt to create distance, it’s more likely that they’re struggling with anxiety, self-doubt, or a desire to be seen as independent. Simply demanding that they talk more isn’t likely to be effective. Instead, creating a safe and supportive environment – one where they feel heard and understood – is key to fostering genuine communication. This requires a shift in perspective: moving beyond the assumption that teenagers don’t want to talk and recognizing that they may be struggling to find the words to express themselves.

Reclaiming Play: How Pretend Can Bridge the Teenage Gap

Alyson Johnson, a TikTok mom (@thebusinessofgolf), offers a compelling and surprisingly effective strategy for reconnecting with her teenage daughter: the art of pretend play. Her approach, rooted in the playful interactions she used with her younger children, has proven remarkably successful in fostering open communication and strengthening her relationship with her teen. She doesn’t force conversations or demand answers; instead, she creates relaxed and inviting scenarios that subtly encourage her daughter to open up. As she describes in her TikTok videos, she’ll transform her closet into a mini-shopping experience, offering treats and compliments while gently suggesting outfits. Another popular strategy is “spa time,” where she creates a pampering session with face masks, wine, and a comfortable setting, prompting her daughter to share her thoughts and feelings – essentially “spilling the tea” as she puts it. This approach isn’t about superficiality; it’s about shifting the dynamic from an interview to a casual conversation. The key is creating an environment where her daughter feels comfortable and cared for, without the pressure of feeling like she’s being interrogated.

The psychology behind this approach is significant. Pretend play activates the same reward pathways in the brain as genuine affection and connection. It triggers a release of dopamine and oxytocin, the hormones associated with pleasure and bonding. By engaging in playful activities, teenagers subconsciously associate their parents with positive emotions, making them more receptive to communication. Furthermore, pretend play provides a safe space for vulnerability. It allows teenagers to express their thoughts and feelings without fear of judgment or criticism, fostering a sense of trust and connection. The fact that it mimics the playful interactions they experienced as children adds another layer of comfort and security, tapping into a deeply ingrained need for connection and reassurance.

Beyond the Initial Reaction: Identifying the Root of Reluctance

While Alyson Johnson’s approach offers a promising solution, it’s important to recognize that not all teenagers respond in the same way. Simply reverting to childhood tactics might not work for every teen, and it’s crucial to understand why a particular teenager is resistant to communication. Before attempting to recreate playful scenarios, it’s essential to explore the underlying reasons for their reluctance. This requires patience, empathy, and a willingness to listen without judgment. Dr. John Bowlby’s attachment theory provides valuable insight into this process. Attachment theory posits that children develop strong emotional bonds with their primary caregivers – bonds that shape their ability to form relationships throughout their lives. When these bonds are disrupted or insecure, it can lead to difficulties with communication and trust. A teenager’s reluctance to talk might be rooted in a history of unmet emotional needs, past hurts, or a fear of vulnerability.

Here are some questions to consider when trying to understand a teen’s reluctance: What’s happening in their life that might be causing them stress or anxiety? Are they struggling with social pressures, academic challenges, or relationship difficulties? Have there been past experiences that have made them hesitant to trust adults? Are they feeling a need to assert their independence and distance themselves from their parents? It’s also important to observe their non-verbal communication – their body language, facial expressions, and tone of voice – to gain a deeper understanding of their emotional state. Sometimes, simply acknowledging their feelings and validating their experiences can be enough to create a space for open communication. For example, saying something like, “I can see you’re feeling frustrated, and it’s okay to feel that way,” can be surprisingly effective in de-escalating tension and encouraging them to share their thoughts.

You may also enjoy reading: Uncovering the 7 Secrets Behind Tales From '85's Bizarre Connection to Stranger Things.

Navigating the Sensitive Terrain: Addressing Discomfort with a Playful Approach

It’s understandable that some parents might feel uncomfortable with the idea of reverting to playful tactics when communicating with a teenager. It can feel disingenuous, almost like pretending to be someone they’re not. However, the key is to understand that pretend play isn’t about deception; it’s about creating a safe and inviting environment. It’s about shifting the dynamic from an authoritative approach to a more relaxed and nurturing one. As Alyson Johnson points out, the goal isn’t to force a conversation; it’s to create an opportunity for connection. The playful elements – the treats, the compliments, the shared activities – serve as a bridge, easing tension and fostering a sense of trust. Think of it less as acting and more as creating a shared experience that naturally opens the door to communication.

Furthermore, it’s important to acknowledge that teenagers are incredibly perceptive. They can often detect insincerity, so it’s crucial to approach playful interactions with genuine warmth and empathy. If a teenager senses that you’re simply going through the motions, they’re likely to pull away even further. Instead, focus on being present, listening attentively, and responding with genuine curiosity and acceptance. Small gestures of affection – a hug, a smile, a word of encouragement – can go a long way in demonstrating your care and support. Ultimately, the goal is to create a relationship based on mutual respect and trust, where both parents and teenagers feel comfortable expressing their thoughts and feelings openly and honestly.

What If Pretend Play Doesn’t Work? Exploring Alternative Strategies

While Alyson Johnson’s approach has proven effective for many teenagers, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. There will be times when pretending simply doesn’t work, and it’s important to have alternative strategies in your toolbox. If a teenager is consistently resistant to playful interactions, it’s crucial to shift your focus to creating a safe and supportive environment without resorting to games or distractions. This involves prioritizing active listening, validating their feelings, and offering unconditional support. Dr. Brené Brown’s work on vulnerability highlights the importance of creating a space where teenagers feel safe to share their struggles without fear of judgment or criticism. This can involve creating regular, unstructured time together – simply being present and available without trying to initiate conversation.

Other strategies to consider include: Scheduled Check-Ins: Instead of randomly initiating conversations, schedule regular, short check-ins – perhaps a 15-minute chat after dinner or before bed. This provides a predictable opportunity for communication without feeling like an interrogation. Shared Activities: Engaging in activities that both you and your teen enjoy – whether it’s watching a movie, going for a walk, or playing a game – can create opportunities for connection and conversation. Expressing Appreciation: Regularly expressing your appreciation for your teen’s efforts and qualities can boost their self-esteem and strengthen your bond. Finally, remember that building a strong relationship with a teenager is a marathon, not a sprint. There will be ups and downs, moments of connection and moments of disconnection. The key is to be patient, persistent, and understanding, and to always prioritize creating a safe and supportive environment where your teen feels loved and valued.

Creating a Haven: Building a Supportive Home Environment for Teenagers

The strategies discussed above – particularly the use of pretend play – are most effective when implemented within the context of a broader supportive home environment. Creating a haven where a teenager feels safe, accepted, and understood is paramount to fostering open communication and strengthening the parent-child relationship. This involves more than simply being physically present; it requires a conscious effort to cultivate a culture of empathy, respect, and connection. Establishing clear boundaries and expectations is also crucial, but these boundaries should be communicated with kindness and understanding, not with judgment or criticism. A supportive home environment is characterized by open communication, mutual respect, and a willingness to listen to each other’s perspectives.

Specifically, consider creating designated “safe spaces” within the home – areas where your teen can retreat when they need alone time or simply a break from the pressures of daily life. This could be a cozy reading nook, a quiet corner in their bedroom, or even a designated spot outside. It’s also important to model healthy communication patterns within your own relationships. Teenagers learn by observing, so if they see you communicating respectfully with your partner, friends, and family members, they’re more likely to adopt those same behaviors. Finally, remember that building a strong relationship with a teenager takes time and effort. Be patient, persistent, and willing to adapt your approach as needed. By creating a supportive home environment, you’re laying the foundation for a lifelong connection based on trust, respect, and mutual understanding.